Dolly All the Time: A GMA Book Club Pick Audiobook Review

What it's about

When Dolly Brick moves back to her seaside hometown of Whitfield, Rhode Island, for the summer, she is driven by a singular, urgent mission: save the family home. At thirty-nine, Dolly has spent decades proving that she can solve any problem thrown her way, a resilience forged when her mother left the family when Dolly was just twelve years old. Now, she returns to ensure that her father and brother do not lose their property, stepping back into a world she may have left behind but never fully forgotten. It is a return rooted in duty, responsibility, and the enduring weight of family loyalty.

The narrative takes an unexpected turn when Dolly encounters Stewart Whitfield, described as an "annoyingly handsome scion" of the wealthy Whitfield family. Stewart finds himself in a precarious position, dealing with a flat tire and the humiliation of a very public breakup. True to her nature, Dolly offers assistance, but this act of kindness quickly evolves into a proposed arrangement. They agree to fake date, a setup that neither anticipated would become anything more than a temporary solution to their respective social and emotional needs.

However, as the summer progresses, the lines between pretense and reality begin to blur. What starts as public dinners and high-society benefits slowly transforms into intimate sunset boat rides and moments of genuine connection. The chemistry between Dolly and Stewart is palpable, with kisses that hit her "bloodstream like a ghost pepper," challenging Dolly’s long-held belief that she must rely solely on herself. The central question of the story becomes whether a relationship built on a lie can evolve into something authentic, testing Dolly’s ability to let someone else in after a lifetime of independence.

Why the audiobook

While the summary does not detail specific audio production elements, the emotional arc of this story—moving from guarded independence to vulnerable connection—suggests that a skilled narrator is essential for conveying the subtle shifts in tone. For a book centered on internal conflict and romantic tension, the right vocal performance can enhance the "luminous" quality described by reviewers, helping listeners feel the warmth of the Rhode Island summer and the intensity of the developing romance. The pacing of a contemporary romance often benefits from an audio format that allows the listener to be swept up in the emotional rhythm of the characters' interactions.

Who it's for

This audiobook is ideal for readers who enjoy contemporary romance with a focus on family dynamics, small-town settings, and the trope of fake dating turning into real love. It is particularly well-suited for fans of the Good Morning America Book Club selections and those who appreciate stories about strong, capable women navigating the tension between duty and personal happiness. However, it may not be the right fit for listeners seeking high-stakes thriller elements, complex magical systems, or fast-paced action. If you prefer romance plots that avoid the "fake dating" setup or are looking for a more serious literary exploration without romantic resolution, this title might not meet your expectations.

The verdict

Dolly All the Time offers a compelling look at love, duty, and the courage required to let go of self-reliance. As an Instant New York Times Bestseller and a GMA Book Club Pick, it delivers on the promise of a gripping summer romance that feels both familiar and fresh. The story’s strength lies in its character-driven approach, focusing on Dolly’s journey from isolation to connection. For those ready to invest an Audible credit in a heartfelt, emotionally resonant romance, this title provides a satisfying and engaging listening experience.